How many times have you seen that someone committed a crime and thought "they deserve the same thing"? Whether it was Casey Anthony or Brock Turner or anyone in between, we've all heard people have extremely harsh reactions to those who commit heinous crimes. However, this is simply a misconstrued idea of fairness. "Fair" is defined as "in accordance with the rules or standards" and the cruel and unusual punishment we witnessed in White Bear is definitely not in accordance with the rules or standards set in the United States, or in Europe. "[A]rticle 3 of the European convention on human rights, now part of our law by virtue of the Human Rights Act. . . states: 'No one shall be subjected to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.'" In our anger and disgust with criminals, it's easy to let ourselves think that they should get what they gave out, but letting our minds stoop to their level doesn't make us better people. Thinking badly of others, even if they are bad people, does nothing to strengthen our character; it only allows for negativity and hate to come into our lives. Watching White Bear, I couldn't help but think that if we all know that what Victoria Skillane did was wrong, why would anyone think it's okay to do it back to her? Just because Victoria may be a terrible person and just because she has done absolutely terrible things, it doesn't mean that she should undergo the torture and confusion and hurt that Jemima underwent. Regardless of who it was happening to, it all seemed to be wrong.
In addition to this kind of punishment being unfair because of the laws against it, we have to decide if this kind of punishment is unfair because of the circumstances surrounding Victoria Skillane's involvement with the kidnapping and murder of young Jemima. Toward the end of the episode, while Victoria is being told who she is and what is happening, Baxter mentions that Victoria claimed to have been "under the spell" of her fiance, Iain Rannoch. Because we, as viewers, are unsure of the nature of relationship between Iain and Victoria, we can't say that this is untrue. It is impossible for us to say that Victoria was lying about this. Iain could have been abusive toward Victoria, Victoria could have been mentally unstable, Iain could have convinced her that they were doing something good, Iain could have been threatening her or someone she loved if she didn't comply; there are plenty of possibilities for why she said she was "under his spell" and what that meant as far as her going along with what he was doing. If this is the case, and she was coerced into this life of crime with Iain Rannoch, then it is hard to hold her accountable for the crimes. It is difficult for me to figure out where I stand on the situation we saw in White Bear because I don't feel like I know all of the facts of Victoria's life, her relationship with Iain, or the way the justice system worked in this episode.
3 comments:
Mary, I agree with you about the punishment. I don't understand why they would want to punish her similarly to what she and her fiance did to the little girl. Yes, it was terrible but you don't treat her bad because she did it. You can't call it wrong and then do wrong yourself. This is a case where it is hard to really know where you stand with the punishment. It's interesting to look into it more, and to see what others think about it.
Mary, your blog post is very good. I like how you made references to actual events that have happened. They made the post more relatable, relevant, and showed the real-life connections to White Bear. You also did a good job of quoting real evidence to back up your argument about punishment. It was also interesting to see your perspective in the closing paragraph. I feel like it's totally true that we viewers can't distinguish whether Victoria did everything of her own free will or was being blackmailed in a sense by her fiancé since he committed suicide and didn't answer for his actions.
Mary, i completely agree with you when you say that people react to crimes with anger and disgust and we jump to say they deserve the same thing to happen to them. We as people must not react in emotion when determining someones punishment.
Post a Comment