"Be Right Back"? Who would’ve thought that meant “Be Right
Back from the dead” … literally. In the film, the characters are a married
couple, Martha and Ash. At the beginning of the film, Ash is completely indulged
in his phone, not paying attention to some of the things Martha says. One day
Ash leaves to run an errand, and never returns home, which worries Martha. She
then finds out that her husband died, so a funeral is held, and she’s torn into
pieces. She seems to be grieving normally at first, the normal depression, but
one of her friends mentioned a program that allowed Martha to communicate with
Ash, even though he was no longer living, and had signed her up for it. Martha
is hesitant at first, but then when she does decide to open the program, she
becomes addicted to it, because she was feeling like ash was actually still
there. The program starts out as just an automated webchat that is programed to
respond like Ash, which isn’t too strange. The next step is automated phone
calls with an imitation of Ash’s voice, which to most viewer still wouldn’t classify
as weird or creepy, then the final step is an actual robotic body that takes
the exact form of Ash’s prior appearance… now that’s what was creepy. The uncanny
resemblance was surreal, and the fact that he performed everyday functions like
a normal human, is mind puzzling in a way. It’s puzzling to the human mind
because we know it’s not the real Ash, but somehow this robot is doing
functions we would, but then again sometimes Martha would have to tell him how
the real Ash would act, and then the robot would respond in that manner. At one
point in the episode, Martha realized that it was not really ash, and she has a
break down towards the robot. The whole process didn’t seem like a healthy way
to grieve a death, because in a way Martha never really let go of Ash in a
sense, even if at the end he’s just up in the attic. Watching the whole film and
how Martha interacted with the robot was quite strange, especially at the end,
where she put him up in the attic, but still allowed her daughter to visit “Ash”.
Why would she even bring robot Ash into her daughter’s life if it’s not the
real thing? Overall, I feel as if we had these types of robots, many would be
uncomfortable, and many would also agree that you wouldn’t be letting go of
that person. Sure, you’d get the comfort for a while, but then come back to
reality and realize that it is not an actual person.
3 comments:
I agree with the points you made. I feel like it is selfish and an unhealthy way to grief. I also think it is no longer that person. It is a new person. In a sense I feel like it is like photoshopping someone into new pictures. It is fake. Sure pictures help us remember, but no new experiences are lived.
I also agree with you on her introducing the robot Ash to her daughter. I feel like if her caught found out what her mom had done, it might hurt more than anything.
I liked what you said: "The whole process didn’t seem like a healthy way to grieve a death, because in a way Martha never really let go of Ash in a sense, even if at the end he’s just up in the attic." The whole process of grieving is letting go. If we have these robots around in the attic, we continue to go in and out of reality.
Post a Comment